George Foreman GGR50B vs GFO240S Electric Grill Review: Which One Should You Buy?

I didn’t buy the George Foreman GGR50B and GFO240S just to compare specs. I bought them because I needed an electric grill that could handle real food without filling my kitchen with smoke. After weeks of cooking everything from thick ribeyes to frozen chicken breasts, I discovered that while they look similar on paper, they live very differently in your kitchen.

My Real-World Test Data

To move past marketing claims, I measured performance using a ThermoPro TP19H for surface temperature and a Govee Air Quality Monitor to track indoor smoke levels (PM2.5).

Test Metric	GGR50B (The Round)	GFO240S (The Oval)
Warm-up to 400°F	11 mins 42 secs	9 mins 15 secs
Max Surface Temp	452°F	438°F
Smoke (PM2.5 Avg)	22 µg/m³	14 µg/m³
Lid Clearance	5.5 inches	3.2 inches

The Coating: George Tough & Safety

Both grills use the proprietary George Tough Nonstick Coating.

Durability: During testing, the coating resisted sticking even with sugary BBQ glazes.
Health & Safety: Both models are confirmed PFOA-free, meaning no toxic fumes are released during high-heat indoor cooking.

Design Intent: High Dome vs Slim Profile

The GGR50B features a high-domed round lid, creating vertical airflow ideal for whole chickens and thick cuts. The GFO240S uses a slanted oval lid, keeping heat closer to the food for faster searing.

Safety Note:
While both grills are marketed as “Indoor/Outdoor,” there is an important legal distinction. The George Foreman GGR50B is ETL-certified for indoor use. While the GFO240S performs well on balconies, the GGR50B is the only model officially approved for countertop indoor grilling.

The Sink Test: Cleaning Reality

Both grills have integrated heating elements, so the plates cannot go in the dishwasher.

Author’s Pro-Tip:
If you have a divided double sink, the GGR50B’s 17-inch round plate will not lay flat and must be washed vertically. This often leads to water splashing onto countertops. The GFO240S fits far more easily in standard sinks and is less frustrating to clean.

Final Verdict: Which One Should You Buy?

Choose the George Foreman GGR50B if:

You cook whole chickens or thick roasts
You want a grill for regular indoor use
You need extra vertical cooking space

Choose the George Foreman GFO240S if:

You live in an apartment or condo
You mostly grill burgers, steaks, and vegetables
You want a grill that’s easy to store and clean

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the George Foreman GGR50B safe for indoor use?

Yes. The GGR50B is ETL-certified for indoor cooking and designed to be used safely under a standard kitchen range hood.

Does the George Foreman GFO240S produce less smoke?

Yes. In testing, the GFO240S produced lower average PM2.5 levels, making it ideal for balconies and smoke-sensitive environments.

Are both grills PFOA-free?

Yes. Both models use George Tough PFOA-free nonstick coating, making them safe for high-temperature indoor grilling.

Can you put George Foreman grill plates in the dishwasher?

No. Both models have built-in heating elements, so plates must be hand-washed.